Kim Stanley Robinson slams Booker ‘ignorance’
American sci-fi author Kim Stanley Robinson has slammed the judges of the well-known Man Booker Prize, saying they hand out the coveted award “in ignorance”, passing over science fiction books he considers to be “the best British literature of our time”.
The prize is awarded to the best novel each year written by a citizen of the British Commonwealth and has a 50,000 pound prize. Earlier this month, the shortlist for the prize was announced, but no science fiction books were to be found on it.
In a scathing article published by New Scientist online last week, Robinson, best-known for his terraforming Mars trilogy (Red Mars, Green Mars and Blue Mars), said the Booker Prize tended to focus on historical novels instead of giving at least some credibility to what he considered to be the literature of here and now today: Science fiction:
“Sometimes these are fine historical novels … But working, like all of us, in the rain shadow of the great modernists, they tend to do the same things the modernists did in smaller ways. A good new novel about the first world war, for instance, is still not going to tell us more than Parade’s End by Ford Madox Ford. More importantly, these novels are not about now in the way science fiction is.”
(via The Guardian, image by AllyUnion)
One Response to Kim Stanley Robinson slams Booker ‘ignorance’
Most debated
- Towers of Midnight: Wheel of Time book 13 (269)
- Dune twitterers ridicule Kevin J. Anderson (61)
- Asimov estate authorises I, Robot sequels (61)
- New Hitchhiker’s Guide book “not very funny” (46)
- How good are the new Dune books? (42)
- Brent Weeks’ next book: Black Prism (30)
- Iain Banks’ Transition gets mixed reviews (27)
- Are science fiction/fantasy writers insane? (19)
- Next Wheel of Time book: Read chapter one (19)
- Brandon Sanderson’s The Way of Kings: Review (19)
Subscribe
Popular topics
a dance with dragons a song of ice and fire australia brandon sanderson dune fantasy forever peace frank herbert george r. r. martin grrm guy gavriel kay haruki murakami iain m. banks janny wurts joe abercrombie joe haldeman karen miller kevin j. anderson kim stanley robinson mistborn neil gaiman neuromancer patrick rothfuss review robert jordan robin hobb science fiction stephanie meyer the fionavar tapestry the forever war the gathering storm the name of the wind the prodigal mage the summer tree the wheel of time the wise man's fear tor twilight twitter uk ursula k. le guin vampire video wheel of time william gibsonLatest posts
- Keeping the Door shuttered
- Patrick Rothfuss’ The Wise Man’s Fear: Review
- A Dance with Dragons is *really* complete
- Review: Iain M. Banks’ The Player of Games
- Guy Gavriel Kay’s Under Heaven: Review
- George R. R. Martin hates A Dance With Dragons delay too
- Early reviews of The Wise Man’s Fear are positive
- Review: Iain M. Banks’ Consider Phlebas
- Review: Hannu Rajaniemi’s The Quantum Thief
- Towers of Midnight: Review
- Peter V. Brett’s The Painted Man: Review
- Brandon Sanderson’s The Way of Kings: Review
- The Left Hand of God: Review
- Robin Hobb’s Dragon Haven: Review
- Gardens of the Moon: Review












Amen, Stan!